Your claim was denied.
Find out if it's bad faith.

What is an insurance claim dispute?

Insurance is a contract. You pay premiums; the insurance company pays valid claims. When the insurer refuses to honor that bargain, you have a dispute. Insurance disputes fall into a few common patterns:

• Outright denial — the insurer says your claim is not covered, your loss didn't happen the way you say it did, or you violated some policy condition.
• Lowball offer — the insurer admits the claim is covered but offers far less than what your loss is worth.
• Unreasonable delay — the insurer doesn't deny or pay. They simply stall, sometimes for months or years, hoping you'll give up.
• Demand for unnecessary documentation — endless requests for paperwork that has already been provided, designed to wear you down.
• Reservation of rights — the insurer agrees to defend a liability claim but reserves the right to deny coverage later, leaving you exposed.

Some of these tactics are perfectly legal. Some are bad faith. The line is whether the insurance company acted reasonably. When the answer is no, the law gives you remedies that go far beyond the original claim value.

What is bad faith insurance?

Every state recognizes that an insurance company owes its policyholder a duty of good faith and fair dealing. That duty means the insurer must investigate claims promptly, communicate honestly, evaluate evidence reasonably, and pay valid claims without unreasonable delay. When the insurer breaks this duty, you can sue for bad faith — and recover damages on top of your original claim.

Common bad faith conduct includes:

• Denying a claim without conducting a real investigation
• Misrepresenting policy terms or coverage
• Failing to acknowledge a claim or respond to communications
• Making lowball offers far below the documented loss
• Hiring biased experts to support a denial
• Cancelling or refusing to renew a policy in retaliation for a claim
• Refusing to settle a third-party claim within policy limits when liability is clear (exposing the insured to a verdict above policy limits)

The most common insurance claim disputes

Insurance bad faith and coverage disputes come up across every kind of policy. The big categories:

• Homeowners and property insurance — hurricane, hail, fire, water damage, theft. Insurers often dispute the cause of damage, the scope of repair, or whether a peril is covered.
• Auto insurance — both your own UM/UIM (underinsured motorist) coverage and third-party liability claims. Often overlaps with personal injury cases.
• Health insurance — denied procedures, "experimental" treatment denials, out-of-network surprise billing, ERISA disputes.
• Disability insurance — long-term disability denials, especially after the 24-month "own occupation" period ends. Social Security disability is a separate process.
• Life insurance — beneficiary disputes, contestability period denials, alleged misrepresentation in the application.
• Business insurance — commercial property, business interruption, directors and officers, errors and omissions, cyber liability, employment practices.
• Workers compensation — denied benefits, premature return-to-work orders. See workers compensation.

What does an insurance lawyer cost?

Most insurance bad faith and disputed-claim cases are handled on contingency. That means you pay nothing upfront, and your attorney is paid a percentage of whatever they recover. If they win nothing, you owe nothing.

A handful of state laws also require the insurance company to pay your attorney fees if you win. Florida (until recent reform), Texas, California, and several others have policyholder fee-shifting statutes. This is one of the most important things an attorney can identify in your first call — whether there is a fee-shifting law that puts pressure on the insurer to settle.

What can you recover in an insurance bad faith case?

The damages available depend on whether your case is a straight contract dispute (just the policy benefits) or a bad faith case (the policy benefits plus more). When you can prove bad faith, the recovery typically expands to include:

The largest bad faith verdicts in U.S. history have been against companies that systematically denied claims. Punitive damages in those cases have reached the hundreds of millions. Most cases settle for much less, but the pattern of conduct often controls the size of the recovery.

Deadlines: do not let your right to sue expire

Insurance disputes have multiple overlapping deadlines, and missing any of them can end your case before it starts. The three you must know:

1. The policy's "suit limitation" clause. Most policies require you to file suit within one year of the denial or the loss. This is often shorter than the state statute of limitations.
2. State statute of limitations for breach of contract. Typically 4 to 6 years from the breach.
3. State statute of limitations for bad faith. Typically 2 to 4 years, often running from the bad faith conduct rather than the original loss.

For ERISA-governed health and disability plans, the deadlines are different again — you usually have 180 days from a denial to file an internal appeal, and you must exhaust internal appeals before suing. Health insurance ERISA cases are a specialty — be sure your attorney handles them.

What to do — and what NOT to do — right now

1. Get the denial in writing. If the insurer told you no over the phone, ask for the denial in writing with the policy section relied on. Federal and most state laws require this.
2. Save everything. The original policy. Every email, letter, and voicemail. Your claim file. Notes on every phone call with the date, time, and adjuster's name.
3. Do NOT give a recorded statement if your insurer asks for one after a denial. Anything you say can and will be used against you. Talk to an attorney first.
4. Do NOT cash a partial-payment check with words like "full and final settlement" or "in full satisfaction" written on it. Cashing it can extinguish your right to seek more.
5. Do NOT sign a release the insurer sends you. Releases bar future claims, including bad faith. Have an attorney review before signing.
6. Document your loss independently. Photos, repair estimates from your own contractors, medical records, expert reports. Do not rely on the insurer's adjuster.
7. Talk to an attorney before responding to the denial in writing. Strategic responses preserve evidence; emotional responses get used in court.

How long does an insurance lawsuit take?

Many insurance disputes settle within 6 to 12 months of an attorney getting involved. Once the insurer realizes you have counsel and that bad faith damages are on the table, the calculus changes — the cost of continued denial often exceeds the cost of paying the claim. If the insurer won't settle, expect 18 to 36 months from filing to verdict, with most cases resolving before trial.

Find an Insurance Claims Lawyer in Your City

See all 100 cities

Related Guides

Insurance Claims FAQ